Main Content
5 Holly Dr, Chatham, NJ 07928
- 6 Beds
- 7 Full ,1 Half Bath
- 0.88acres
Living at 5 Holly Dr
It is not every day that a home and property this extraordinary comes on the market. Arguably the most stunning property in Rolling Hill, this 2007 built custom 7,700 square foot home, was built for the discerning buyer who values quality and character, with its signature feature of Connecticut Fieldstone throughout. Built for entertaining and everyday living, both inside and out, this iconic home sits majestically in a picture perfect estate-like setting, amazing neighborhood association with social events; proximity to New York City, easy access to Midtown Direct train (via Boxcar app parking) and convenience to fantastic shopping and restaurants in downtown Chatham and Madison. Extraordinarily crafted by renowned builder R.P. Bennett with every amenity imaginable. Outstanding architectural details, high-end artistry and expert workmanship at every turn. Exquisite property with outstanding outdoor entertaining spaces. 600 Square Foot Bluestone Patio with Pergola and Fireplace overlooking flawlessly landscaped backyard. Sensational Master Suite with Sitting Room/Exercise Room, 2 AMAZING Walk In Closets and out of this world luxurious bath. Gorgeous Family Room opening out to outdoor entertaining space. Elegant Living and Din
It is not every day that a home and property this extraordinary comes on the market. Arguably the most stunning property in Rolling Hill, this 2007 built custom 7,700 square foot home, was built for the discerning buyer who values quality and character, with its signature feature of Connecticut Fieldstone throughout. Built for entertaining and everyday living, both inside and out, this iconic home sits majestically in a picture perfect estate-like setting, amazing neighborhood association with social events; proximity to New York City, easy access to Midtown Direct train (via Boxcar app parking) and convenience to fantastic shopping and restaurants in downtown Chatham and Madison. Extraordinarily crafted by renowned builder R.P. Bennett with every amenity imaginable. Outstanding architectural details, high-end artistry and expert workmanship at every turn. Exquisite property with outstanding outdoor entertaining spaces. 600 Square Foot Bluestone Patio with Pergola and Fireplace overlooking flawlessly landscaped backyard. Sensational Master Suite with Sitting Room/Exercise Room, 2 AMAZING Walk In Closets and out of this world luxurious bath. Gorgeous Family Room opening out to outdoor entertaining space. Elegant Living and Dining Rooms. 2 Mud Rooms. 2 Laundry Rooms. 2 Front Entrances. All bedrooms with ensuite baths. Huge Lower Level with 2 Recreation Rooms, Play Room, Sauna and Full Bath. 3 Car Garage with Tesla charger. Don’t miss this once in a lifetime buying opportunity for the discerning homeowner seeking the best that Chatham has to offer!
Room by Room Details of 5 Holly Drive, Chatham
First Level
- 2-Story Entry Foyer featuring double solid mahogany front doors, wide plank oak hardwood floors, wainscoting, custom designer hanging lantern, dramatic vaulted ceiling with bay window and additional window above, curved staircase with custom railings, 2 Coat Closets, crown molding, baseboard molding
- Powder Room featuring marble/limestone mosaic floor tile, furniture style custom wood vanity with decorative paint, marble countertop, Toto toilet, 2 light sconce, flush mount light fixture, designer fixtures, baseboard molding, crown molding
- Dining Room featuring double French doors with transom at entry, wide plank oak hardwood floors, wainscoting, coffered ceiling, custom designer chandelier, recessed lighting, wall of French doors with side windows and transoms opening to Family Room
- Living Room featuring French door at entry with transom above, wide plank oak hardwood floors, 2-sided gas fireplace with custom millwork mantel and stone surround, wall sconces, coffered ceiling, wainscoting, lantern, recessed lighting, French doors with transoms above, double French doors with transom to rear hallway, oversized floor to ceiling window at front
- Family Room featuring wide plank oak hardwood floors, 2-story floor to ceiling fieldstone fireplace, custom chandelier, recessed lighting, 2 sets of French doors with side windows forming an arch and opening to Bluestone Patio, crown molding, baseboard molding, 2nd floor gallery overlooking Family Room
- Ensuite Guest Room (Bedroom #6) featuring wide plank oak hardwood floors, oversized windows overlooking rear property, custom roman shades, semi-flush mount designer light fixture, recessed lighting, Closet, baseboard molding, crown molding, Bathroom featuring limestone flooring, furniture quality vanity, limestone countertop and mirror frame, oversized shower with frameless glass and tile surround, flush mount light fixture, 2 light sconce over mirror, fan, designer fixtures, Toto toilet
- 4 - Season Sun Room featuring stone step, windows with transoms at 3 exposures, heated stone floor, other side of gas fireplace with floor to ceiling fieldstone surround and brick hearth, French sliding doors leading to private and covered Bluestone Patio, lantern, recessed lighting, crown molding, baseboard molding
- Gourmet Chef’s Kitchen featuring limestone flooring, custom cabinetry throughout including glass door cabinetry, granite countertops, furniture quality custom center island/breakfast bar featuring scalloped granite countertops, tumbled natural stone backsplash, double sink, designer fixtures, 2 custom designer pendant lights above island, recessed lighting, integrated Sub Zero refrigerator, integrated Sub Zero freezer, Wolf professional 6-burner gas range with double ovens and griddle, LG stainless built-in microwave, Miele integrated dishwasher, decorative custom hood with natural stone tile and wood detail, built in Desk Area with granite countertop and concealed storage, pot filler, crown molding
- Breakfast Room featuring bay of arched windows, limestone flooring, French door opening to Bluestone Patio, custom chandelier with silver and gold leaf detail, crown molding
- Butler’s Pantry featuring wide plank oak hardwood floors, custom built in cabinetry including glass door cabinetry, granite countertops, copper sink and copper fixture, wallpaper, crown molding, baseboard molding, lantern, U-line beverage refrigerator
- Side Entry Foyer featuring mahogany door with sidelites, wide plank oak hardwood floors, oversized double door Coat Closet, access to Garage, Rear Staircase with custom railings, lantern, baseboard molding, crown molding
- 2nd Mud Room Area featuring wide plank oak hardwood floors, Walk In Pantry with floor to ceiling shelving, access to Garage, lantern, crown molding, baseboard molding
- Office/Study featuring wide plank oak hardwood floors, oversized window overlooking side yard, sliding French door with transom to private and covered Patio, recessed lighting, crown molding, baseboard molding, Closet
- Heated 3 Car Garage with carriage house style automatic doors, Tesla Charger, custom built in Mud Room Area with built in cubbies and hanging storage, stone steps at Mud Room Entry
Second Level
- Second Level Landing featuring curved Balcony overlooking Entry Foyer and opens to gallery hallway overlooking Family Room and adjoining bedrooms, Rear Staircase, recessed lighting, lantern at rear
- 900 square foot Master Bedroom Suite featuring vaulted ceiling, wide plank oak hardwood floors, 2-sided gas Fireplace with custom carved wood mantel and stone surround, built in area above fireplace for TV, recessed lighting, custom designer lantern, 3 light sconce, custom roman shades, crown molding, baseboard molding custom chandelier, 2 Walk In Closets with custom shelving and hanging storage, double French doors opening to Master Bath
- Master Sitting Room/Exercise Room featuring vaulted ceiling, wide plank oak hardwood floors, windows at 3 exposures, second side of 2-sided Fireplace with floor to ceiling stone surround, custom designer lantern, recessed lighting, TV hookup, custom Roman shades
- Master Bathroom featuring vaulted ceiling, limestone flooring with inset tiles, tile wainscoting, radiant heat, 2 furniture quality wood vanities with marble countertops, custom designer chandelier, two 3-light sconces, custom cut large wall mirrors with stone surround, Grohe fixtures, oversized frameless glass door shower with dual body sprays, claw foot soaking tub, private room for toilet, Toto toilet, crown molding
- Ensuite Bedroom #3 featuring wide plank oak hardwood floors, dramatic cathedral ceiling, designer lantern, recessed lighting, custom window panels, Walk In Closet with custom shelving and hanging storage, sliding French doors with transom out to Balcony overlooking rear property, Bathroom featuring limestone flooring, furniture quality vanity, limestone countertop and mirror frame, Jacuzzi shower over tub combination with tumbled tile surround with decorative border, recessed lighting, 3 light sconce over mirror, fan, Grohe fixtures, Toto toilet crown molding, baseboard molding
- Ensuite Bedroom #4 featuring wide plank oak hardwood floors, dramatic cathedral ceiling, designer lantern, recessed lighting, custom window panels, Walk In Closet with custom shelving and hanging storage, row of triple windows overlooking rear property, Bathroom featuring limestone flooring with mosaic tile inset, furniture quality vanity, limestone countertop and mirror frame, shower over tub with stone tile surround with decorative border, recessed lighting, 3 light sconce over mirror, fan, designer fixtures, Toto toilet, crown molding, baseboard molding
- Ensuite Bedroom #5 featuring wide plank oak hardwood floors, cathedral ceiling, children’s loft/reading nook accessed by ladder, designer lantern, recessed lighting, custom roman shades, Walk In Closet with custom shelving and hanging storage, Bathroom featuring limestone flooring, furniture quality vanity, limestone countertop and mirror frame, shower over tub with stone tile surround with decorative border, recessed lighting, 3 light sconce over mirror, fan, designer fixtures, Toto toilet, crown molding, baseboard molding
- Ensuite Bedroom #2 featuring wide plank oak hardwood floors, cathedral ceiling, designer lantern, recessed lighting, custom roman shades, 2 Double Door Closets with custom shelving and hanging storage, Bathroom featuring limestone flooring, furniture quality vanity, limestone countertop and mirror frame, tub/shower combination with stone tile surround with decorative border, recessed lighting, 3 light sconce over mirror, fan, designer fixtures, Toto toilet, crown molding, baseboard molding
- Laundry Room featuring limestone flooring, custom built in utility sink, upper built in cabinetry, crown molding, baseboard molding, recessed lighting
- Accessed through Laundry Room is Attic space for additional storage
Lower Level
- 9+ foot ceilings throughout with Bose surround sound system
- Landing Area featuring limestone flooring, lantern, baseboard molding
- Finlandia Sauna
- Full Bathroom featuring limestone flooring, furniture quality vanity, limestone countertop and mirror frame, oversized shower with frameless glass and tile surround, recessed lighting, 3 light sconce over mirror, fan, designer fixtures, Toto toilet, Linen Closet, access to Landing Area and Recreation Room
- Recreation Room featuring carpeting, floor to ceiling gas stone fireplace and hearth, recessed lighting, baseboard molding, sconces
- Play Room featuring carpeting, recessed lighting, baseboard molding, media closet, alcove with curtain, open to Recreation Room and 2nd Recreation/Music Room
- 2nd Recreation/Music Room featuring carpeting, Double Door Closet with floor to ceiling shelving, recessed lighting, baseboard molding, alcove with above ground windows, lantern, access to Storage Room
- Storage Room featuring carpeting, 3 Double Door Storage Closets, area for shelving, above ground window
- Laundry Room featuring limestone flooring, LG Tromm front loader washer and dryer, built in utility sink, built in upper cabinetry, baseboard molding, recessed lighting
- Mechanical Room
- Rear Hallway featuring limestone flooring, stone steps to French door to backyard, Double Door Coat Closet, 2nd Closet, lantern, baseboard molding, above ground window
Front Yard/Backyard
- .88 Acre
- 2-wide Driveway with parking for at least 6 cars
- Designer lanterns at both front entries
- Bluestone front walkways to Front Entry and Second Front Entry
- Connecticut fieldstone front exterior
- Fully fenced in meticulously landscaped front and backyard featuring lush lawn, specimen plantings, blooming trees and perennials
- 600 Square Foot Bluestone Patio with Pergola and custom motorized shades at top and sides and wood railings overlooking private and manicured lawn, lattice detail at top, includes Outdoor Wood Burning Fireplace featuring Connecticut fieldstone chimney, access to Family and Breakfast Rooms
- Dramatic Bluestone and Connecticut stone staircase off of Patio cascading down to rear yard
- Off of Study, Private Garden/Bluestone Patio with stepping stones, decorative gravel and stone staircase leading to backyard
- Off of Sun Room, Private Garden/ Bluestone Patio with stepping stones, decorative gravel, access to Lower Level, vegetable garden
- Side area with custom fence, decorative Arbor and gate, other side with custom fence and gate
- Bluestone stepping stones/path, Stone retaining walls surrounding property
- Front and Back Irrigation System
Additional Features/Upgrades
- Honeywell Generator
- Tesla Charger in 3 Car Garage
- Sound System throughout 1st Level, Outdoors and Master Bedroom
- Whole House and Outdoor Intercom System
- Tuff n Dry basement waterproofing system
- Connecticut fieldstone and cedar shakes exterior
- Wood shake roof
- Underground utilities, 325 AMP electrical service
- Louvered wood shutters
- Connecticut fieldstone chimneys
- Nuvo audio surround sound, TV, phone and internet ready
- 3-zone Trane AC
- 12-zone baseboard heat including radiant heat in Master Bath
- New Furnace (2018)
- Two 75 Gallon Water Heaters
- Central vacuum system
- Security System
- Water Filtration System
- Air Purification System
While you should stop by the Jacob Morrell House, where George Washington is said to have lodged while his army assembled in outlying fields, you don’t need to love history to enjoy Chatham. Located less than an hour’s drive west from New York City, this quaint town not only has a rich history, but also is one of the top suburbs in New Jersey to live because of its highly- rated schools, green spaces and charming town center. Residents absolutely adore the picturesque historic downtown area and the societal elements that come with bumping into neighbors and friends at the many unique shops and restaurants that are found there. Then there is the quiet, residential appeal of neighborhoods that are populated by gorgeous center-hall colonial and craftsman style homes adorned with American flags and front porch rockers. Annual events, such as Fishing Derby at Kelley’s Pond, the Fishawack Festival, the Fourth of July Parade and the Green Fair help in preserving the small town feel. The abundant green spaces, including parks, reservations and conservation areas, make it hard to believe you’re so close to one of the greatest cities in the world.
LP: List Price at time of sale
DOM: Days On Market
Commuting Info
- 42 minutes to NYC

While you should stop by the Jacob Morrell House, where George Washington is said to have lodged while his army assembled in outlying fields, you don’t need to love history to enjoy Chatham. Located less than an hour’s drive west from New York City, this quaint town not only has a rich history, but also is one of the top suburbs in New Jersey to live because of its highly- rated schools, green spaces and charming town center. Residents absolutely adore the picturesque historic downtown area and the societal elements that come with bumping into neighbors and friends at the many unique shops and restaurants that are found there. Then there is the quiet, residential appeal of neighborhoods that are populated by gorgeous center-hall colonial and craftsman style homes adorned with American flags and front porch rockers. Annual events, such as Fishing Derby at Kelley’s Pond, the Fishawack Festival, the Fourth of July Parade and the Green Fair help in preserving the small town feel. The abundant green spaces, including parks, reservations and conservation areas, make it hard to believe you’re so close to one of the greatest cities in the world.
Questions? Appointments
Call 973-936-9129or send us your message!
Mortgage Estimator
Nearby Listings
Big or Small, we sell them all
Email Property Alerts
Sign up and receive email alerts when new listings come on the market.
