46 Headley Pl, Maplewood, NJ 07040

  • 5
  • 3 full, 1 half

Perfect Colonial in phenomenal cul-de-sac location!  Move right in to this delightful 5 Bedroom, 3 ½ Bathroom gem located in the sought after Orchard Park section of Maplewood with blue ribbon schools, a short distance to downtown Maplewood Village and South Orange train stations. Beautifully situated on one of Maplewood’s best blocks (great block parties, trick or treating and holiday BBQs), this house has it all.  Gorgeous hardwood floors and original woodwork throughout. Magnificent renovated Gourmet Kitchen with chic white shaker style cabinetry, Thermador appliances, marble countertops and a lovely Breakfast Room. Elegant Living Room, Dining Room and Den.  Dreamy Sun Porch.  Master Bedroom Suite with custom closets and spa-like bath with marble.  3 other roomy bedrooms on 2nd Level (Bedroom 4 has 2 Walk In Closets).  Third Level Guest/Au Pair Suite. Tons of potential for Lower Level as Recreation Room/Play Room. Meticulous landscaping with paver patio and organic gardens.  Close to Orchard Park, downtown South Orange, Maplewood and Midtown Direct Train, this home won’t last!

Room by Room Details of 46 Headley Place, Maplewood

First Level

  • Entry Vestibule featuring original tile flooring, storage hooks, wainscoting, stucco walls and ceiling, French door to Entry Foyer
  • Entry Foyer featuring hardwood floors with walnut inlay, original oak woodwork, semi pendant light fixture, baseboard molding, staircase with runner to 2nd Level, Coat Closet with original door with beveled mirror
  • Living Room featuring hardwood floors with walnut inlay, original fireplace with brick surround, oak mantle and tile hearth, built in bookcases flanking fireplace, recessed lighting, stucco ceiling and walls, original oak baseboard and crown molding, oversized windows, blinds
  • Den featuring hardwood floors with walnut inlay, windows at 2 exposures, French door to Sun Porch, stucco walls and ceiling, original oak baseboards, crown molding, original built ins with open and concealed storage, window blinds
  • Sun Porch featuring wood floor, bead board ceiling, ceiling fan/light fixture, removable screens/windows at 2 exposures
  • Dining Room featuring hardwood floors with walnut inlay, designer chandelier, original oak baseboard and crown moldings, original oak wainscoting, stucco walls and ceiling, oversized windows, blinds
  • Gourmet Chef’s Kitchen featuring hardwood floors, custom shaker style cabinetry by Pennsylvania woodworkers (handpainted by the cabinet maker’s wife), gray island, glass door cabinetry, open shelving, marble countertops, subway tile backsplash, Thermador fully integrated refrigerator/freezer, Thermador stainless cooktop, Thermador double wall ovens, custom wood hood, fully integrated Thermador dishwasher, Shaw farm sink, recessed lighting, designer pendant lighting, pantry with floor to ceiling shelving, Breakfast Area with custom built in banquette/table/bench, open shelf and designer light fixture, all new plumbing, swinging door to basement steps
  • Powder Room pocket door, tile flooring, wall mount sink, open shelving

Second Level

  • Second Floor Landing featuring hardwood floors, custom hall runner, baseboard molding, stucco walls
  • Master Bedroom Suite featuring hardwood floors, 2 huge custom closets with custom storage, baseboard molding, crown molding, flush mount light fixture, oversized windows, wood blinds
  • Master Bathroom featuring pocket door at entry, marble hexagonal floor tile with border, custom vanity with marble countertop, frameless glass door shower, subway tile throughout, medicine cabinet, plantation shutters, 3 light sconce, recessed light, fan
  • Full Hall Bathroom featuring mosaic floor tile, pedestal sink, medicine cabinet, 2 light sconce, recessed light, fan, plantation shutters, subway tile throughout, Linen Closet
  • Bedroom #2 featuring hardwood floors, baseboard molding, crown molding, flush mount light fixture, stucco walls, wood blinds, Closet with shelving and hanging storage
  • Bedroom #3 featuring hardwood floors, baseboard molding, crown molding, flush mount light fixture, stucco walls, wood blinds, Closet with shelving, drawers and hanging storage
  • Bedroom #4 featuring hardwood floors, Playroom Nook, baseboard molding, crown molding, flush mount light fixture, stucco walls, wood blinds, 2 Walk In Closets (1 cedar)

Third Level

  • Carpeted staircase and Landing/Office Area, industrial light fixture, eave storage
  • Bedroom #5 featuring carpeting, vaulted ceiling, baseboard molding, flush mount light fixture, Closet, eave storage
  • Full Hall Bathroom featuring tile flooring, beadboard wainscoting, pedestal sink, tub, built in storage, flush mount light fixture, sconce, tilt mirror

Lower Level

  • Wood staircase to lower level
  • Tiled landing with door to backyard
  • Partially finished Recreation/Exercise Room
  • Laundry Room featuring LG Washer and Dryer, utility sink
  • Storage/Utility Room with additional refrigerator


  • Fully fenced in yard with professional landscaping
  • Organic lawn and beds
  • Compost Bin
  • Bluestone back door landing
  • Paver Patio
  • Detached 2 car garage

Additional Features/Upgrades

  • Exterior painted (2018)
  • Kitchen renovated (2015)
  • Two 2nd floor Bathrooms renovated (2015)
  • Newer Roof (2011)
  • Newer windows (2004)
  • Central AC
  • Updated electrical panel
  • External hookup for generator
  • Newer “environmentally friendly” insulation
  • Reverse osmosis water system (rental)
  • Original doors and crystal hardware throughout

Read More »

Sue Adler

CEORealtor Associate 973-936-9129
  • ?>

#maplewoodnj on Instagram



    Sign up and receive email alerts when new listings come on the market.


    Sorry, no similar listings available at this time.

    About Maplewood


    Maplewood is a thriving commuter neighborhood that combines the charm of small town living with the convenience of living just half an hour away from Midtown Manhattan. The area is youthful, energetic and extremely family-friendly. Maplewood provides a social atmosphere with many community events and an exciting downtown area while maintaining a peaceful residential appeal. With quality schools, scenic open spaces, shopping and entertainment options, and gorgeous properties, Maplewood is clearly a top-notch community to live in!  

    Maplewood School Information

    The School District of South Orange and Maplewood  is served by The Montrose Early Childhood Center, seven elementary schools (Clinton, Jefferson, Marshall, Seth Boyden, South Mountain, Tuscan Elementary, and South Mountain, Annex), The South Orange and Maplewood Middle Schools as well as Columbia High School. All of these institutions have a positive reputation for academic rigor and boast extensive lists of impressive accomplishments that result from the strong emphasis on academic excellence and social responsibility as the foundation for all  their educational endeavours. Columbia High School is known as one of the most academically progressive high schools in the state of New Jersey and has been recognized nationally for its academic excellence with a Blue Ribbon award from the US Department of Education.The advanced academic programs, committed staff, full-range student support, and extensive extracurricular programs allow students to become lifelong learners and achieve acceptance into some of the nation’s top universities. The South Orange-Maplewood Adult School stands as a testament to the value that this community places on education, offering continuing education classes in a diverse range of subjects for adults in the community who want to keep expanding their worldviews. For the summer months, the district provides a highly praised children’s camp, the South Orange-Maplewood Community Summer Program.


    Maplewood Commuting Info

    Maplewood residents have convenient access to the Maplewood Train Station which provides direct access to New York Penn Station, Newark, and Hoboken, and The Port Authority on New York and New Jersey is nearby, featuring additional rapid transit options throughout New York. The area also has its own Jitney Bus Service that provides easy public transport to and from the Maplewood Station for the everyday commuter, and multiple bus routes in the area ensure that there are even more transport options to New York and throughout New Jersey.

    Maplewood is also situated near to routes 24, 280, I-78, 124, The New Jersey Turnpike, and The Garden State Parkway by car to ensure easy travel options throughout the state, and Newark Liberty Airport, a major continental and international gateway, is only a 20 minute drive away.



    • 29 Minutes to NYC



    Questions? Appointment? Call 973-936-9129 or send us your message!

    Listing Contact Form

    • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.